Chapter 9. Managing People During Research

Don’t shift your weight, look always at your mark but don’t stare, be specific but not memorable, be funny but don’t make him laugh. He’s got to like you, then forget you the moment you’ve left his side.

Rusty, Ocean’s Eleven

The elements of a research initiative vary based on scope and type. This makes research seem hard. Fortunately, one common element across any quantitative or qualitative research is you and your team. While you may not be able to control environment or participant engagement, your practice and awareness of social graces can help research feel natural. This chapter looks at some of the softer skills that make research look more natural to participants and stakeholders alike. These skills are not meant to be prescriptive, and vary by culture and environment. We will spend some time exploring the most common interactions.

Host and Guest Norms

For any research where you interact directly with people, it is important to understand and respond appropriately to social or professional cues. This conveys a level of respect that leads to a more natural discussion with participants. One common analogy of this dynamic is the relationship between actors on a stage and the audience. The audience is aware that actors are reading from a script, performing a fictional or historical scene, and transporting the viewer to another place. But through suspension of disbelief and the skill of the actors, the audience is absorbed in the environment rather than set outside of it. Research is the same way. Often described as the “Wizard of Oz technique” because researchers pull the strings behind a literal or figurative curtain, research is about interacting with participants in a seemingly natural way, regardless of the actual behind-the-scenes impact.

Dress Appropriately for Office Visits

When you are visiting office settings, it is a good idea to ask your business stakeholders about dress code and office practices. Even if you always visit your client in a suit and tie, asking this question is critical. On many occasions we have been asked to remove our neckties or leave our jackets behind so that employees don’t mistake us as managers, or worse, an internal audit team.

Equally important is being dressed for the specific environment. The attire in a medical center is drastically different than that of a construction site. It is not unheard of for researchers shifting between different projects to have to change quickly between sessions, like Clark Kent/Superman in the phone booth.

Be a Gracious Guest During Home Visits

Home visits are measurably more challenging than office visits, as an individual is inviting you into their personal space. While it may feel awkward, take cues from your environment. If you see a line of shoes along the door, ask your host if you should remove your own.

At the same time, when a participant agrees to meet you in their home, they often feel the social pressure of hosting you. To balance social graces with the level of propriety desired of research, we recommend accepting a glass of water (assuming it is offered). You do not need to drink the water, but by merely accepting it you are fitting an expected social interaction and putting your participant at ease.

Respect Participants’ Personal Space

Whether you are meeting at a participant’s place of work or in their home, it is important to not be in their personal space for too long. This applies to both before and after a research session.

Don’t arrive too early

While it is strongly encouraged that you arrive early to research sessions and ensure that all systems work, do not do this at the participant’s desk. Find a coffee shop around the corner, or on another floor of the building, and set up as much of the testing environment as possible. While it feels cumbersome, walking through the halls of an office with an open laptop connected to a screen-sharing device is preferable to losing the first 10 minutes of a research session to technical issues.

Leave no trace behind

Just as setup for a session should not take place in a participant’s personal space, neither should the breakdown after a session. While this is important in office settings, it’s critical with home visits. After thanking participants for their time, pack up as efficiently as you can.

Then, almost just as importantly, don’t sit in your car in the participant’s driveway, or linger outside their office door. Take the extra five minutes to drive around the block or, even better, to a local coffee shop. At this point, take the time needed to sort papers, reset any technology, save files, and prepare for the next session.

Follow Screen-Sharing Best Practices

Remote sessions are easier in the sense that personal space is not a factor. Still, it is important to follow certain social norms. If you’re sharing the participant’s screen, warn them that anything on their screen will be visible to the observers. This includes the tasks being explored but also anything on the participant’s desktop. We have inadvertently seen personal or racy content on participants’ screens more times than we care to admit.

If the warning wasn’t enough and something unsavory or unprofessional comes across the screen, the best course of action is to try to ignore it. If the problem persists or is distracting, don’t be afraid to use technical challenges as an excuse and ask the participant to close other applications in order to avoid “overwhelming the testing tool.”

Cultural Considerations

Just as important as host and guest norms are more subtle cultural norms. Research spans the globe, and thus requires awareness and sensitivity to how guests, greetings, and information are exchanged.

Cultural considerations may be as subtle as the definition of personal space but also include conversational cues or body language. While this book cannot go into detail on every variation, we strongly encourage discussing with business stakeholders any cultural or social norms when you’re visiting international research locations.

Set the Right Tone

We speak differently to our colleagues than we do our managers. We have different inflections when discussing life and work with significant others than with parents and friends. With this in mind, the tone you have with research participants sets the baseline for your relationship with them throughout the research session.

All too commonly, an employee learns they are being used in a research study and internally hears, the company wants to find a way to remove my position. It is also common that they see researchers as an extension of management.

An easy way to alleviate any concerns about job security is to frame your role as researcher like so: “I’m here to make your job easier by understanding how you approach your work. This may include frustrations or workarounds you’ve uncovered. Rest assured that while we are recording, our aim is to keep your information as anonymous as possible and we can go ‘off the record’ any time you feel it’s necessary.”

Know When to Call “Scene”

In improv, a scene is considered complete when one of the actors calls “Scene!” during the performance. While Chapter 10 explores in depth some improvisational techniques as a tool for research, you can’t literally shout “Scene!” or “Done!” in front of a research participant. Still, it is important to infer when a participant is finished providing information on a given topic or with the research session altogether. While research often employs the laddering method to probe on the “why” of a task, a good researcher knows how to stop just short of pushing too far.

You might define “done” for a participant when they’re giving you the same answer two times in a row, or changing from thorough explanations to one-word answers. Be sensitive to how your participants respond to your cues. It is very difficult to gain someone’s trust and comfort once the cadence and ease of a conversation is lost.

Small Talk Matters

A lot of this chapter circles around the idea of small talk. While one aspect of this is filling gaps in conversation and recognizing an individual’s comfort level, another aspect is having a respectful tone of voice.

In the medical world, this is referred to as “bedside manner” and refers to the doctor’s tone and attitude toward a patient. In the research world, it translates to treating participants with respect and establishing a strong teacher and apprentice role, where they can guide you as the researcher through their experiences.

Priming Questions

Small talk is a learned skill. The easiest way to practice it is to use priming questions. These include demographic questions including age, profession, and familiarity with a product or toolkit. Small talk goes beyond that, though, and offers a more conversational tone to the session. Don’t be afraid to offer some of your own personal information, as it may help open your participant up to the discussion. Be careful, though. This is not a friend or colleague you are meeting with but a research participant. While sharing personal information is appropriate, always make sure you are maintaining an appropriate level of professionalism and not marring the data collected.

Taking Notes

We already discussed the role of the moderator and the note taker, but we did not focus on how notes are captured. Since we want to focus on human conversations, it is important to have a system that is as unobtrusive as possible. The two options for capturing notes are straightforward: pen and paper or on a computer. While there is no right answer for one or the other, there are considerations for each.

Pen and paper

Pen and paper offers the ease and efficiency of going where you go, not being tied down to an outlet, and being unobtrusive. Taking notes on a legal pad or directly on a copy of the discussion guide is an easy way to naturally capture information in the context of the session.

Some drawbacks to pen and paper are around sharing. You need to scan, photograph, or transcribe your notes before they can be distributed. This leads to a bigger concern if you cannot read your shorthand after the fact. We prefer handwritten notes, and have developed our own shorthand that we then transcribe into a digital tool as soon as possible after a session.

Digital notes

Digital notes work too and offer you the option to immediately share and distribute notes. A number of tools pair digital audio recording with typed notes, providing more context to what was said.

One important consideration for digital notes is the cadence of your typing. As you start and stop writing, a participant can easily ignore (if they even hear) the scratch of your pen on paper. The clicking of keys, however, can make a participant self-conscious about what they are saying and how you are reacting. If digital note taking is your preferred method, we suggest finding a consistent cadence so it seems as if you never stop typing—even if this means typing “the quick brown fox jumped over the lazy dog” as you wait for feedback. This allows the sound of the keyboard to fall into the background so the participant isn’t distracted by your note taking.

Warming Up

Warming up, whether it is the oven before cooking or your muscles before playing sports, is critical. Research is no different. We refer to warming up as the softer side of research because the transition from practice to research often happens seamlessly and, depending on the scale of the research, may require us to revisit these exercises throughout a session.

Still, research hinges on warming up. Think for a moment how a participant would behave if you walked into a room and immediately started asking them personal financial or health-related information? These are sensitive topics, and balancing the rich data with the appropriate level of humanity and empathy is key to gathering good data. In longer interviews and discussions, taking breaks from the script to hear a tangential story allows participants to open up and is just as valuable as their insights to product design.

Soft skills and warming up aren’t exclusive to the beginning of a session. Near the close of sessions it is not uncommon to circle back to more social discussions. In this way, the personal “meat” of a discussion is sandwiched between softer, more lightweight questions. This can go a long way in leaving a participant feeling heard and respected, and with positive feelings toward your product and research team.

Exercises: Making Small Talk

Small talk, or warming up, is a soft skill that’s not easily taught and requires active practice. While this book will not make you an expert in small talk, the following exercise takes less than five minutes a day and can help you become more comfortable in these social situations.

Office Small Talk

Take a mental audit of your coworkers. Who do you talk to on a regular basis? Who might you know in passing but have not built a relationship with? Focus on the second list and, once a day (or once a week), make an effort to strike up a conversation with them. This doesn’t have to be anything overly personal or awkward, but as you cross paths in the mailroom or kitchen, rather than simply saying hello ask what projects they are working on, how they like the new office renovations, or how they fared during the last snowstorm. Make a concerted effort to change whom you speak with each day and cycle back on the colleagues you spoke with early on. Who knows, an added benefit could be some stronger office relationships too.

Coffee Talk

If you work in a small office, or would rather practice with total strangers, think of the coffee shop you frequent. Do you simply pay your barista and go on your way? Do you stand in line staring at your phone? Instead of doing that, strike up a conversation with the clerk or other patrons. We don’t mean that you should pry, but using simple icebreakers like “I hope the seasonal latte comes back soon” will build your confidence in having conversations with people you don’t know well.

Parting Thoughts

An entire book could be spent on soft skills in kicking off research. We have personally experienced the various graces and blunders outlined in this chapter. While the ones covered here are important, all researchers come up with their own methods to handle social graces in a research and product setting. The important thing is that you don’t lose sight of the personal touches that make people comfortable in a research session.

To become comfortable with your own approach, start by imitating your mentors. From there, you can find your voice and make research your own. This ownership and personalization is critical to being true to your goals and comfortable in your own skin. The following chapter focuses on ways to shift and pivot during research to build your own research persona.

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset