8

Negotiating for Win-Win Solutions

image_30

Learning Objectives

No matter how well you prepare, no matter how well you present your material to the customer—indeed, despite everything you do—the customer will seldom, if ever, buy the product based solely on your presentation. Does this mean you should not prepare the best sales presentation possible? Of course not. The presentation is the starting point for a successful buyer–seller relationship. But negotiating and working with customers to develop a win-win solution to their problems are at the heart of the contemporary selling process. There are many occasions when the customer will have legitimate, specific questions or objections about the nature of your material. Negotiations are the process whereby customer objections and questions are resolved.

This chapter explores the process of negotiating with customers. We will identify customer objections and how you can learn to respond successfully when customers raise objections about your product. It describes specific negotiating strategies designed to help you work through customer concerns. Finally, it discusses the sales manager’s role in negotiating win-win solutions.

After reading this chapter, you should be able to:

  • Understand the process of negotiating win-win solutions.
  • Know the common objections most salespeople encounter working with customers.
  • Know the basic points to consider in negotiating with customers.
  • Understand the specific negotiating strategies.
  • Understand the sales manager’s role in negotiating win-win solutions.

Negotiating Win-Win Solutions

“Obstacles are those frightful things you see when you take your eyes off your goal,” Henry Ford observed. Dealing with customer objections is an element of the relationship-building process that many salespeople do not enjoy. However, as Ford pointed out, it is critical to keep your eyes on your goal: building the buyer–seller relationship. When a customer shares objections, it gives the salesperson an opportunity to strengthen the relationship.

The objections customers raise during the sales presentation are one reason salespeople are so important to the relationship-building process. If customers readily accepted the presentation, the company could just mail them a brochure or send them to the company’s website to view a PowerPoint presentation. It is salespeople and their unique ability to answer customer objections that enables the company to sell products to customers.

This chapter examines the delicate process of negotiating win-win solutions. It is not particularly difficult to understand the basics of negotiation, but doing it well requires training, practice, and experience. By the end of the chapter you will have the tools to negotiate successfully with customers. The chapter also examines the role managers play in supporting the salesperson during the negotiating process.

Negotiations: the Heart of the Win-Win Solution

Many books on personal selling speak to the issue of “customer objections” and how salespeople should deal with them. They seem to think that objections are a problem that salespeople need to manage. The contemporary selling process considers customer objections an opportunity for the salesperson to create a win-win solution, and that is the goal to focus on during the presentation. Refer to the Model for Contemporary Selling at the beginning of the chapter to see where we are in the process.

Too often salespeople believe that when the customer wins, they lose. Or the customer believes he or she has lost and the salesperson has won. They think there can be only one winner. Presenting customer concerns as problems suggests that if salespeople can somehow develop a scheme to win, they are successful. This is simply not the case in contemporary selling.1 If either the buyer or the seller loses, both have lost. An unhappy buyer is likely to seek out other suppliers, and the relationship will suffer. If, on the other hand, the seller is forced into an unprofitable contract, the customer will ultimately bear the cost through less service, poorer-quality products, or some other problem. In either case, there is no winner.2 Successful buyer–seller relationships are based on both parties being satisfied with the customer’s purchase.

Webster’s dictionary defines negotiation as the act of “conferring with another so as to arrive at the settlement of some matter” and “arranging for or bringing about through conference, discussion, and compromise.”3 Notice the definition speaks about discussion and compromise with the customer. It does not include words like “exploitation” and “manipulation.” We have spoken about the importance of building relationships based on mutual respect and customer value. Negotiating through customer objections is a critical element in that process.

Common Customer Concerns

Casual observation may suggest there are many different customer concerns; however, when you look closely, it is clear the anxieties fall into five areas. Note that customers may mask their true concern with general anxieties. Successful salespeople know that when they hear a customer objection, they need to clarify and determine its true nature. Exhibit 8.1 is a summary of the five main customer concerns.4 Let’s examine them.

Exhibit 8.1 Summary of Customer Concerns

  • Do I need your product?
    • − Product need
    • Your product need
  • Do I trust your company?
    • − Unease about your company
    • − Loyalty to existing supplier
  • I don’t really know you.
  • I need more time to consider your product.
  • Is this your best price?

Do I Need Your Product?

Customer objections regarding the product fall into two broad areas that require different approaches to deal with the customer’s concern.

Product Need. First, the customer may not be convinced that there is a need for the product. This is especially true if the customer has never used a product like it. He or she may simply not see the value in buying the product or the need that it satisfies. This view can be summarized as, “We’ve always done it one way. Why should we start something new now?”

Apple is one of the most successful technology companies in the world creating such hugely popular products as the iPhone, iPad and Apple Watch. Many people may not recall that Apple has also had some product failures, consider the Apple Newton. When it was introduced in 1993, the Newton was one of the original personal digital assistants (PDAs) and ahead of its time. Unfortunately, many corporate customers could not see the need for a personal organizer and thought of it as an expensive calendar and meeting organizer. Corporate buyers asked why they should spend $500 for a calendar. Where Apple failed, companies like Palm succeeded by demonstrating these were really little computers capable of many things besides being a calendar. Today, PDA functions are built into cell phones or other mobile wireless devices like tablets or "wearbles" (Apple Watch). The Newton lives, but only with a group of enthusiasts, as Apple discontinued the product in 1998.5

Ultimately, customers must see a clear and convincing reason to buy the product. If they don’t, you shouldn’t be surprised if they choose not to buy. Keep in mind that customers are not usually risk takers. With new products they are likely to wonder if the technology is too new or unproven. They may also question if it is significantly better than their current solution. The fundamental question is “Do I really need your product?” Key to the answer is a well-conceived value proposition that explains clearly how the product will benefit the customer and how it will be better than the existing solution.

Your Product Need. A much more common concern regarding product is whether the customer needs your product. Perhaps the configuration of your product is different or your competition’s product has features that aren’t on yours (or vice versa). Almost anything about your product may be of concern to the customer. Careful preparation is critical in dealing with questions about your product’s superiority. This is why you must have a thorough knowledge of your competitor’s products and services.

Since the customer has been using your competitor’s products, he or she knows their configuration, terminology, and product benefits very well. You must clearly define your product’s features, advantages, and benefits (FABs) so the customer will understand the value proposition of your company’s products over your competition. Again, change is not easy, and buying your product means the customer will have to learn a new product, so your value proposition must consider the cost of change. Put simply, your product cannot be just as good as the competition because that will not be sufficient reason for the customer to change. Your product must be demonstrably better.

Do I Trust Your Company?

If a customer asked, “Why should I trust your company?” would you be able to answer? As we have discussed, contemporary selling is based in part on mutual respect and trust between buyer and seller, including trust between the buyer’s company and your company. In most cases customers already have a supplier. They may not be totally satisfied with that supplier, but they’re familiar with them. They know whom to call to get a problem resolved. They are also familiar with that company’s policies and procedures. You must overcome the customer’s reluctance to change suppliers. Research suggests that as sales become more complex (for example, bundled IT solutions) customers demand a higher level of trust with the selling organization. Perhaps this is not surprising given the increased perceived risk and longer term commitment associated with making expensive, highly complex purchase decisions.6

There are two types of customer objections regarding the salesperson’s company. Often these two issues work together to create a formidable concern for the customer.

Unease about Your Company. If customers are not aware of your company, they may simply be concerned about your ability to deliver when, where, and what they need. This is a legitimate concern, as they are putting their company at some risk by choosing you as a supplier. They need to know that you will do what you promise in the presentation.

Customers can be concerned about your company for many reasons. If you are small, they may be apprehensive about whether you can deliver what they need or whether you are even going to be in business in two years. If you are big, they may fear they will not be a valued customer. These objections can be difficult to overcome. How can you prove to the customer that your company will be around in two years? How can you demonstrate you will deliver what the customer needs when and where it’s wanted, every time? Perhaps the customer has read or heard something negative about your company.

Loyalty to Existing Supplier. A customer who has objections about your company may be showing loyalty to or satisfaction with the current supplier. The customer may say, “I have been buying from Mr. McAllaster at Steadfast for years and they have been excellent. I never had a problem they didn’t fix.” In those situations it is not that your company has done anything wrong; rather, your competitor has done things right. This problem must be handled carefully, or you will anger the customer and lose the opportunity to build the relationship. Long-term relationships with suppliers can create some challenges for the salesperson. Read the Ethical Dilemma to see how strategy partnerships sometimes present difficult problems.

Directly confronting the customer with negative comments about the supplier will almost surely fail. Remember, customers don’t like change, and speaking critically about someone they have had a relationship with for a time will not endear you to them. The best approach is to stay focused on your product and company.

I Don’t Really Know You

Customers may be concerned about the ability of a new, inexperienced salesperson to learn their business or their commitment to the company. (Is the salesperson going to be there for a while?) The salesperson has to earn the customer’s respect. When salespeople are new, customers may ask to see their supervisor or want someone more experienced to handle their business. In these situations, it is important to be very prepared and demonstrate knowledge of the customer’s value proposition. The salespeople shouldn’t become defensive about their education or qualifications. Rather they should use the concerns as an opportunity to build the relationship and ask those customers to put them to the test. The salesperson is asking for a chance at their business.

Ethical Dilemma ifig0018.jpg

Helping a Customer or Something else?

Emily Hatch knows that this is an important moment in her company’s relationship with World Manufacturing. For the past three years she has been the account manager for World, and business has grown steadily. Her company, Accurate Instruments, supplies a key component for World’s leading product. World has bought this component from Accurate since the product was introduced over six years ago.

During that time, the relationship between World and Accurate has developed into a close strategic alliance. Emily’s assignment three years ago signaled to everyone in the company that senior management thought Emily had a great future. She has not only managed the account well but actually increased business.

As she sits talking with Ben Griffin, senior vice president of manufacturing for World, there is a conflict. Recently the CEO of World told him to get a 10 percent cost reduction from all suppliers. The CEO said this is due to a recent sales slump. However, Ben believes it is a short-term tactic designed to enhance cost-cutting measures proposed by the CEO for the upcoming annual shareholders’ meeting.

Ben points out that, as a major supplier to World, Accurate Instruments is expected to reduce its prices. However, he also proposes a solution. If Accurate will send an invoice showing a 10 percent reduction in prices, he will hold it. He’s sure that once the shareholders’ meeting is over in three weeks, Emily can send a new invoice with the original pricing.

The last thing Emily wants to do is create any friction between World Manufacturing and Accurate Instruments. She knows Ben Griffin and believes he must be under tremendous pressure to propose such a plan.

Questions to Consider
  1. Should Emily submit the false invoice to World Manufacturing? Why or why not?
  2. How much negotiating should a salesperson do when confronted with a customer making unfair or unethical demands?
  3. What role should Emily’s manager play in dealing with this situation?

Selling is a people business, and occasionally your personality will not be compatible with the customer’s. Keep in mind Henry Ford’s quote: “Stay focused on the goal.” While you and the customer may not be friends or even get along, what matters is the relationship between your companies. Of course, you should notify your manager of the problems and seek his or her help on how to address personal compatibility issues. (We will talk about this later in this chapter when we examine the manager’s role in negotiations.)

Even experienced salespeople run across personality conflicts when they take on a new account. Customers often develop a relationship with a salesperson as well as the selling company. When a salesperson is replaced, the new person and customer will naturally go through a period of getting to know one another. During this period, the salesperson should be supported by management so the customer understands the company has complete confidence in the new person. Some companies rotate the sales force to prevent this situation from developing with customers. The focus should always be on the relationship between the company and the customer, not the salesperson and the customer.

I Need More Time to Consider Your Product

Every day salespeople hear: “I need more time to think about your proposal.” Customers have a legitimate concern about making a purchase decision too quickly. If the purchase involves several parts of the company (for example, the decision to build a new plant or develop a new product), there will most likely be a committee involved in the purchase process. In some industries (defense, airlines), the decision to purchase may take a year or more. Boeing, a world leader in manufacturing large commercial aircraft, is typical. Its Boeing 787 Dreamliner took years to develop, test, and market to commercial airlines around the world. When a customer says he or she needs more time to think about the purchase, it may be true.

However, customers frequently ask for more time because they wish to delay or stall the final decision for several reasons. First, customers may be reluctant to make a decision because of the uncertainty of something new. You are asking them to trust you, your company, and your solution to their problem. While you may know it to be the best solution to their problem, they may be anxious.

Global Connection ifig0017.jpg

Negotiating Price in a Global Marketing Place

  1. Define value for the customer. Customers all over the world are focused on getting value for their purchase. It is important for the professional salesperson to help the customer understand the true value of the sale. Often this involves prices but not always. For example, customers may be willing to trade a higher price for better reliablity or purchasing flexibility.
  2. Help the customer feel better about the purchase. Every purchase requires the customer to make decisions and successful salespeople understand that a critical part of the sales process is helping the customer understand the wisdom of their purchase. It is important to minimize concerns that feed the buyers’ fear of change.
  3. Probe the customer for unspoken concerns. In some cultures, for example Japan, buyers are reluctant to state all their concerns and defer the decision until later. Salespeople must probe the customer to be sure all concerns have been addressed.
Questions to Consider
  1. Do you think customers reference price in the same way around the world?
  2. What are the primary challenges for negotiating price around the world?

The second (and more likely) scenario is that you have failed to prove the value proposition. The customers do not see the benefits of your product over their existing situation. It is important to realize, however, they are not saying no. They are indirectly asking you to build a stronger case for your product. Again, this is an opportunity to build the relationship. Go back into your presentation and ask questions to ascertain the source of the customers’ anxiety. Summarize the value proposition to reinforce the positive results from a purchase decision.

Is This Your Best Price?

Salespeople will consistently tell you price is the concern they hear most often. This concern is voiced in many ways: “Your price is too high,” “I don’t have the budget right now,” “I’d like to purchase your product but not at that price,” “I can’t justify that price for your product.” In many cases, the customer has legitimate objections about the price of your product. Global Connection provides some useful tips for negotiating price in a global market place. Many customers, especially professional buyers, are directed to buy the lowest-cost product. Often they are evaluated and rewarded on their ability to drive down the price of the products they purchase. Professional buyers at Walmart are trained to negotiate the lowest price possible.

However, while price is a legitimate customer concern, a more likely explanation is that the customer has not accepted the value proposition. Remember that value is a function of price and perceived benefits. A customer who does not perceive that the product benefits exceed the price will not be inclined to purchase the product. You are left with two options to make the sale: lower the price until it is below the product’s perceived benefits, or raise the perceived benefits until they exceed the price. A customer who says your price is too high is really saying, “The benefits I perceive for buying your product are not greater than the price you are currently charging.” Here are some guidelines to follow in dealing with the price concern.

Add Value to the Total Package. Customers buy a bundle of benefits that includes the product, financial terms, customer support, the company’s reputation, warranties—and not least, you. Getting customers to see the entire package of benefits will transform their perspective on the value of your presentation.

Price Should Never Be the Main Issue. When salespeople make price the center of the presentation, they are risking the long-term buyer–seller relationship. Price is an important part of the presentation, but the salesperson should never bring it up until after he or she has clearly defined the product’s features, advantages, and benefits. Then they should mention price in the context of the value proposition equating it to outstanding service and quality products.

Price Is Your Friend, Not Your Enemy. Many salespeople treat price as the enemy and run away from it at the first sign of customer concern. When a salesperson offers price concessions, he or she is saying they believe the price is too high. This position will not enhance the value of the salesperson’s product with the customer. Indeed, it will harm the customer perception of the product and create doubt as to the true product value. Embrace the price as an opportunity to highlight the value of the product benefits and customer service.

Basic Points in Negotiating Win-Win Solutions

As you have seen, a number of customer objections can affect buyer–seller negotiations. Dealing with these objections may seem like a daunting challenge, but successful negotiations are about understanding the nature of buyer–seller relationships and recognizing some general guidelines for managing buyer concerns effectively. Exhibit 8.2 gives guidelines for negotiating win-win solutions.

Exhibit 8.2 Guidelines for Negotiating Win-Win Solutions

  1. Plan and prepare.
  2. Anticipation enhances negotiations.
  3. Say what you mean and mean what you say.
  4. Negativity destroys negotiations.
  5. Listen and validate customer concerns.
  6. Always value the value proposition.

Plan and Prepare

Just as preparation is important to a successful presentation, it is crucial to managing customer concerns. Knowledge of your customer, anticipation of your customer’s objections, and a carefully developed sales presentation can do more to resolve customer objections than almost anything else. Keep in mind that the customer knows why you are there and has agreed to see you, which shows a willingness to consider your product and company. The more you have thought about and dealt with possible objections before the presentation, the more likely the customer will be to accept your proposal. At a minimum, you have shown you are committed to his or her satisfaction and positioned yourself for success in the future.

Anticipation Enhances Negotiations

Basic customer objections run across all buyers and do not change over time. With training and experience, salespeople can learn to anticipate objections while preparing for the presentation.7 We spoke in detail in chapter 7 about getting ready for a great sales presentation. A critical part of that preparation is to preempt customer objections. When you address a concern in your presentation, will the customer raise it anyway? Possibly, but by anticipating the customer’s apprehension you will have a response already developed and can reinforce it if he or she brings the objection up again. Interestingly, research suggests that high performing salespeople are able to learn and retain more information than low performance salespeople. At the same time they create more "if-then" scenarios preparing for the sales presentation. In essence they do a better job of anticipating objections by customers.8

One benefit of anticipating customer objections is that you can solve a problem before the customer has a chance to mention it. Taking the time to work out solutions to customer objections in advance lets the salesperson offer choices so the customer doesn’t feel compelled to say no. For example, if you foresee price as a customer concern, develop different combinations of benefit bundles (service levels, product quality, and financial terms) to demonstrate your willingness to work with the customer.

Say What You Mean and Mean What You Say

Plain-speaking, honest answers go a long way toward building trust and reducing customer anxiety. When customers come to realize that you have their best interests in mind and deliver on statements during the presentation, their overall concern about the company and about you is diminished. When you say you are going to follow up on a question and get back to the customer later that day, you must do it. Admitting you don’t know the answer to a question is always a better strategy than trying to bluff. Customers don’t expect you to have all the answers, but they do expect you to find out.

When customers trust you and your company, they are less likely to be concerned about price, ability to deliver products on time, product quality, and customer service. Of course, this means a great deal of communication inside your own company. When a salesperson says, “Yes, we can deliver the products by next Friday,” he or she must have the knowledge to support that delivery date. Because you are the point of contact with the customer, your ability to represent the company honestly and accurately is essential in reducing customer objections about you and your company.

Negativity Destroys Negotiations

There is often a lot at stake in negotiations with the customer (purchase order, commissions, and reputation, just to name a few), and negotiations can become very tough. Both parties seek to do the best job for their respective companies, and conflict on a variety of issues (price, delivery, credit terms, product configuration) is a natural part of the process. There’s always a risk of becoming emotionally involved in the proceedings. Frustration, even anger, at the customer, the circumstances, or the way the process is going is always possible and difficult to control. It is natural to defend yourself when you perceive an attack. But controlling your anger is critical to successful negotiations. Allowing negativity to enter the negotiations will lead to a similar reaction in the customer. Once this happens it is very difficult, sometimes impossible, to get the negotiations back on track.

When the situation is getting frustrating and you feel anger, step back from the process. Ask questions to keep the customer involved and allow him or her to voice concerns. Staying connected to the customer while managing your frustration is essential. It can help to remember the customer is likely frustrated as well. Maintaining control of one’s anger demonstrates a willingness to work with the customer that will often be appreciated.

Listen and Validate Customer Concerns

Customers simply want the salesperson to listen and respond to their concerns. As we have discussed, the selling process asks customers to take a risk. New customers are risking a great deal, but even if they have been customers for a long time the selling process, by definition, is about change. Even though a salesperson has addressed their objections, customers may still feel the need to voice specific worries during the negotiations.

The concern may seem trivial to the salesperson, but it is important to the customer. Listening and validating the customer’s concern acknowledges that it has value.9 It is important to listen actively to customer concerns (as discussed in chapter 7). Focus on the customer, make sure you understand what he or she is saying, and then respond to the concern.

Always Value the Value Proposition

The most effective tool for negotiating with customers is a well-developed value proposition. Carefully explaining the benefits of your company, products, services, and yourself goes a long way toward alleviating customer objections during the presentation. When you link benefits to overall value, customers will tend to worry less about price (a major customer concern), as well as other issues, and focus more on how you have addressed their needs.

Value is more than price. While customers often direct their discussion toward price, it is the salesperson’s responsibility to seek out and identify the real value of the company’s product to the customer. The value added by your company could take many forms, including better customer service, enhanced product quality, or improved buyer–seller communication. After identifying the value added by your company and communicating that to the customer in the sales presentation, you may need to go back and reinforce it during negotiations.

Specific Negotiation Strategies

There are nine basic strategies for dealing with customer concerns. Each one can be effective in the right situation. However, learning how and when to use them requires training and experience. Unfortunately, using the wrong strategy or employing a particular strategy incorrectly can derail the negotiations.

There are going to be circumstances where the customer will not be satisfied with the negotiations no matter what you say or do. In those situations, it may be necessary to pull back from the negotiations to maintain the customer relationship. It is paramount to maintain the relationship. Never allow your personal feelings to affect negotiations.

Exhibit 8.3 details the various negotiation strategies.

Exhibit 8.3 Negotiation Strategies

  1. Question
  2. Direct denial
  3. Indirect denial
  4. Compensating for deficiencies
  5. Feel—felt—found
  6. Third-party endorsements
  7. Bounce-back
  8. Defer
  9. Trial offer

Question

In the question strategy you take the customer’s concern, turn it into a question, and refocus on one or more strengths of your value proposition. The goal is to get the customer thinking about your presentation in a new way and contrast his or her concern against an advantage. Notice in our example that the customer is concerned about the price of the product relative to the competition. The salesperson asks the customer to consider that, while the product has a slightly higher price, it is of better quality.

Think about possible customer objections before the presentation and formulate questions to address those concerns. Questions are a relatively nonthreatening method of handling customer objections, but you must listen to the customer’s comments to develop a question that addresses the concern. Here’s an example of this technique.

Buyer: Your product is 10 percent more than your competitor’s. That’s too much.

Seller: Yes, it is slightly more expensive, but do you agree that the higher quality of our product means fewer returns and lower service costs for your company in the long run?

Direct Denial

Perhaps the most confrontational strategy for dealing with customer objections is the direct denial method, which involves an immediate and unequivocal rejection of the customer’s statement. Customers may find this kind of direct disagreement threatening and have a very negative reaction.

You are probably wondering if you should ever use this strategy to address a customer concern. When a customer states a clearly false and damaging statement about you, your company, or your product, it is important to respond to the statement immediately. Allowing such ideas to continue is usually more damaging than provoking the customer. If it is a simple case of misinformation, stating the facts directly will probably clear things up for the customer.

Critical to the success of this strategy is the manner in which you address the customer misstatement. If you are offensive and insulting, the customer will likely react negatively to the statements. The focus should be to create a win-win negotiation, but being condescending or demeaning eliminates that outcome.

Buyer: I was told recently that you had to recall all of your production for the last two months because of a faulty relay in your switch mechanism.

Seller: I’m not sure where you could have heard that. We have not had a recall on any of our products for over 10 years. If you like, I can provide the data for you. Your source was mistaken.

Indirect Denial

Indirect denial takes a less threatening approach. The salesperson begins by agreeing with the customer, validating the objection before explaining why it is untrue or misdirected. For this strategy, the customer’s concern should have at least some validity. Perhaps you are priced slightly higher than the competition, or your product features do not match up exactly with the current supplier’s. Address the concern by first acknowledging that part of what the customer is saying is true.

If the customer has raised a totally valid point, reconsider this strategy. You don’t want to deny a legitimate customer point that makes the presentation weaker. If it is not possible to deny the customer concern with the information at your disposal, do not use this strategy.

Buyer: Demand for your products is strong. I’m not convinced you will be able to meet my order on time.

Seller: You are correct. My company has enjoyed tremendous success and we are thankful our customers have adopted our product. However, we pride ourselves on not missing order deadlines, and our customers will verify that. I will be working with my manufacturing and logistics departments to ensure on-time delivery of your order. One last note: you can check the status of your order any time by logging on to our website. If you are not satisfied, call me.

Compensating for Deficiencies

No product is perfect. Every product is a combination of advantages and disadvantages. Companies design, develop, and build products based on a bundle of features (product characteristics) they believe will be accepted in the marketplace. Customers must balance what they want with what they are willing to pay (the value proposition). They realize that the perfect product doesn’t exist and they must decide which features, advantages, and benefits are most important to them.

Customers frequently object to some element of the product’s FAB mix. The salesperson’s task is to move the customer from focusing on a feature his or her product performs poorly to one in which it excels—to compensate for deficiencies in the product. The new feature must be important to the customer. Talking about a feature the customer is not interested in will only make the situation worse.

First, acknowledge the validity of the customer’s concern about the feature in question. Second, move the customer to the new product feature by pointing out the trade-off between the two. If the customer insists the product must have this one feature, it is time to consider offering products that are closer to meeting that demand, even if you do not enjoy an advantage with these products. Ultimately, the customer is right and you must adjust your product offerings to meet his or her demands. Note that the example shifts the focus from response rate (one product feature) to price and quality.

Buyer: The response time on your product is too slow. Your competitor’s response time is nine-tenths of a second, which is two-tenths of a second faster.

Seller: I agree with you. My product is two-tenths of a second slower. However, please note that it also costs 25 percent less per unit than the product you are currently using. You indicated price was an issue in your decision. I would also add that my product has 10 percent fewer returns than your current supplier. I have the numbers right here if you care to take a look.

Feel—Felt—Found

There are times when customer objections are more connected to their attitudes, opinions, or feelings than to facts. “In my opinion” and “I believe” are indicators that the customer is moving from a fact-based to a feeling-based concern. In these situations, the feel—felt—found technique can be helpful.

First, acknowledge the customer’s feeling (“I can see how you feel”). Second, extend the same feelings to a larger audience (“Other customers have felt the same way”). Third, counter with a legitimate argument (“However, I have found that our products… ”). The sequence is important and should be followed exactly.

At first glance, this may seem like a good strategy for dealing with customer objections, as you are relating very specifically to the customer. However, it is an old technique and one most professional buyers know. Using it on the wrong person can create the impression you are being disingenuous and the presentation is prepackaged.

Buyer: In my opinion, your products are overpriced and not worth the extra cost.

Seller: Our products are slightly more than the competition’s and I can certainly see why you feel that way. Other customers have felt that way at first. However, when they take the time to examine my company’s higher product quality and improved customer service (which result in lower service costs) they have found the overall value of the product to be worth the investment. Let me show you those numbers again.

Third-Party Endorsements

This strategy is based on the use of outside parties to bolster your arguments in the presentation. It can be used in combination with other strategies, such as feel—felt—found and indirect denial. The use of third parties to endorse you, your company, or your product does add credibility. However, it is essential to get their permission before using them for an endorsement. Many customers do not wish to have their names used in this way. We spoke earlier of potential conflicts of interest if the customer you are calling on is a competitor of the endorsing party. In addition, you always run the risk the customer will have a negative reaction to the third party. Use this technique only when you know the relationship between your customer and the third party.

Buyer: Your customer service has been questionable, and it is important I have tech support 24/7.

Seller: I agree with you that our customer service was not what it should be several years ago. However, we made the investment to improve customer service, and it is now among the best in the industry. Gracie Electronics felt as you did but was willing to try us and is now one of our most satisfied customers.

Bounce-Back

An experienced salesperson knows when to turn a customer concern into a reason for action. The bounce-back is effective in many different situations (appointment setting, negotiating, and closing). It is more aggressive than some of the other strategies, so be careful not to seem pushy.

This technique can be particularly effective when you hear objections about needing more time or a lower price. Indeed, when you understand the value proposition of your product you will note that often it is designed to save the customer time and/or money. So when the customer raises a concern about time or cost, you have an opening to reinforce the cost savings and time efficiencies of your product.

Buyer: I’ve listened to your presentation but need more time to consider your proposal.

Seller: I can appreciate that this is a big decision for your company. However, delaying this commitment only costs your company money. As we agreed earlier, my products will save nearly 40 percent in manufacturing costs over your existing supplier. Delaying this decision simply means higher costs for your company.

Defer

Customers seldom let a salesperson complete an entire presentation without interrupting to ask a question. If the concern they raise is one you will address later in the presentation, you may want to defer it until you have had the chance to explain other material. Most of the time the customer will understand and let you continue with the presentation. Occasionally, the customer will demand an immediate answer. If pressed, you should respond immediately. However, suggest that the customer listen to the entire presentation in order to fully appreciate all the features, advantages, and benefits of the product.

The defer strategy is most common when the customer raises a concern about price early in the presentation before the salesperson has a chance to fully define the value proposition. Simply stating the price of the product without fully explaining the benefits bundle may lead the customer to the wrong conclusion—that the price is too high. You need to evaluate the customer and determine if he or she needs the information at that point to assess the product’s value. (Some people process information differently than others.)

Buyer: (before the full value of the product has been explained): What is the cost of your product?

Seller: I can appreciate your interest in knowing the price of the product, but I would ask you to hold off just a minute until I know a little more about your product requirements and determine which of our products best suits your needs. Then I will be happy to show you what kind of investment you need to make.

Trial Offer

One of the best strategies to calm customer objections is the trial offer, which allows the customer to use the product without a commitment to purchase. It is especially effective with new products, because the customer can try the product, become familiar with it, and see the product benefits without risk.10

Here are some guidelines to keep in mind. First, the trial offer does not take the place of a good sales presentation. Second, clearly define the terms of the offer so there will be no confusion. A customer who does not know the offer is for three days may keep using it even after your company has sent a bill. These misunderstandings can do much more harm than good. Third, make sure the customer is fully checked out on the product. Don’t leave a client with a product he or she does not know how to use correctly.

Buyer: I’m not willing to make a commitment to your copier today. It seems complicated and hard to use.

Seller: I can appreciate your concerns. How about I have our service department install one for you and let you try it for one week. I will come by and demonstrate it for you. You are welcome to use it for one week without any obligation. If at the end of the week you do not believe this copier solves all your copying needs, call me and I will come pick it up.

The Sales Manager’s Role in Negotiating Win-Win Solutions

As mentioned earlier, the sales manager plays an important supporting role during negotiations between salespeople and customers. Salespeople need to know they have the authority to negotiate with customers and resolve their concerns. This may mean negotiating aspects of delivery, product configuration, even price. Salespeople need to have the confidence that they can negotiate whatever is necessary and (unless it violates company policy) the sales manager will endorse the negotiations. This means company policy must authorize salespeople to negotiate with customers. It is also important that managers work hard to provide the resources to help the salesperson satisfy the customer’s needs; when resources are limited (such as in recessions) cutting back on sales force can lead to lower customer satisfaction.11

Company personnel must also know the salesperson speaks for the company. It can be very damaging if people inside the company question the salesperson’s negotiations once the customer has committed to buy.

In situations where the customer objections exceed the salesperson’s authority, the manager is there to step in and continue the negotiations. It is important for the manager to be fully briefed on the negotiations to that point. As the negotiations continue, the manager should keep the salesperson involved, since he or she will be responsible for taking care of the customer once the negotiations come to a successful conclusion. The manager’s support is critical to the salesperson’s success in negotiating win-win solutions.

Summary

No matter how well a salesperson prepares or presents the material to the customer—indeed, despite everything the salesperson does—the customer will seldom (if ever) buy a product based only on the presentation. Customer objections are part of the relationship-building process, and negotiating win-win solutions separates successful salespeople from the rest of the pack. Negotiations are the process of arranging with customers (through conference, discussion, and compromise) a successful resolution to their concerns.

While there may appear to be many different customer concerns, in reality there are only five. The first is “Do I need your product?” There are two types of product concerns. First, the customer needs to be convinced he or she needs the product at all. Second, the customer may already use the product but buy it from a competitor. You need to convince the customer that your product is demonstrably better than the competition.

The second fundamental customer concern is “Do I trust your company?” Customers may not know your company and doubt your ability to deliver what, when, and where they require. Or they may have a good relationship with their current supplier and see no reason to change companies. In both cases, you need to work hard to show customers that your company is fundamentally capable of handling their orders and is better than the competition.

A third customer objection has to do with the salesperson—“I don’t really know you?” Customers may need to be persuaded that trusting you is not risky. A fourth concern is “I need more time to consider your product.” While there can be legitimate reasons why the customer needs more time, this is often an attempt to stall the purchase decision. The customer may be saying, “You have not yet made a strong value proposition and I don’t fully understand the value of your product relative to the competition.”

The final customer concern is “Is this your best price?” Customers often focus on price to the exclusion of other, more critical factors. The salesperson’s job is to help the customers understand the value of the total benefits package and focus on issues other than price.

There are six basic points to consider in preparing to negotiate win-win solutions: (1) plan and prepare, (2) anticipation enhances negotiations, (3) say what you mean and mean what you say, (4) negativity destroys negotiations, (5) listen and validate customer concerns, and (6) always value the value proposition. Following these guiding principles greatly improves the probability of success in negotiations.

The nine basic negotiating strategies are (1) question, (2) direct denial, (3) indirect denial, (4) compensating for deficiencies, (5) feel—felt—found, (6) third-party endorsement, (7) bounce-back, (8) defer, and (9) trial offer. Knowing when and where to use each strategy is critical. Using the wrong one at the wrong time (such as the direct denial) can create very negative feelings in a customer.

Finally, the sales manager plays a significant supporting role. First, he or she empowers salespeople to negotiate with customers. If customers don’t believe salespeople have the authority, they will not negotiate. Second, the sales manager may on occasion have to get directly involved in the negotiations. In those cases, it is important to keep the salesperson involved.

Key Terms

negotiation

stall

direct denial

indirect denial

compensate for deficiencies

bounce-back

defer

trial offer

Role Play ifig0019.jpg

Before you begin

Before getting started, please go to the Appendix of chapter 1 to review the profiles of the characters involved in this role play as well as the tips on preparing a role play. This particular role play requires that you be familiar with the chapter 7 role play.

Characters Involved
  • Alex Lewis
  • Rhonda Reed
Setting the Stage

Assume all the information given in the chapter 7 role play, but flash back to before the sales call on Tracy Brown (Alex’s longtime buyer at Max’s Pharmacies). Alex and Rhonda have scheduled a meeting a few days prior to the Max’s sales call so the two of them can brainstorm to develop a list of potential concerns/objections that Tracy may have regarding stocking the new Upland product “Happy Teeth” in the front-end space in her eight stores. Rhonda wants to role-play a buyer–seller dialogue about these potential concerns before Alex makes the actual sales call, so he will have a chance to practice handling Tracy’s various potential objections. Tracy’s concerns will relate both to end users of the product (customers who shop at Max’s Pharmacies) and to her own business (why Max’s should or should not stock and promote Happy Teeth in its very limited front-end space).

Alex’s Role

Work with Rhonda to develop a thorough list of likely concerns/objections Tracy may have about Happy Teeth. Be sure all nine negotiation strategies in this chapter are represented at least once in your list. (You can have some represented more than once.) Refer to the sample buyer/seller dialogues in the section on specific negotiation strategies for ideas on developing the list and the role-play dialogue.

Rhonda’s Role

Work with Alex on the above.

Assignment

Present a maximum 10-minute role play in which Alex plays himself in a mock sales call on Tracy. (Rhonda gets to role-play Tracy.) Execute the nine specific negotiation strategies presented in the chapter. Be sure Rhonda asks tough questions and brings up concerns/objections in a way that is firm yet fair. Be sure Alex uses proper negotiation techniques to overcome each objection. At the end of the mock sales call, Rhonda should take no more than 5 minutes to provide constructive feedback/ coaching to Alex on how well he used the negotiating strategies.

Discussion Questions

  1. Have you ever bought a new (or used) car? What were the negotiations like? Did you enjoy the negotiations? Why or why not?
  2. Do you think it is really possible to have win-win negotiations? Why or why not?
  3. You have made an appointment with a new potential customer. As you prepare for the presentation you realize this person has never purchased this kind of product before. What do you do?
  4. You have been meeting with a potential new customer regularly for three months. She likes the product but finally admits a loyalty to the existing supplier. The buyer says, “I have known Judith Gunther for 10 years and she has been a very good supplier.” What do you do?
  5. “I don’t know you, and I very much liked working with Oscar Jones. Why was he transferred to Chicago?” The customer you have just met for the first time is unhappy because of his relationship with the old salesperson. As a new salesperson, how would you win over this important customer?
  6. Your company has just announced a 7 percent price increase on your entire product line and you are meeting with your most important customer. She announces that your competitor has already been to see her and will not raise prices for at least 24 months. What do you do to keep the customer?
  7. Think of a time you were talking with someone and felt yourself getting angry. How did you handle it? What steps would you take to keep from getting angry with a customer who was being unreasonable?
  8. Your product is clearly not as good as the competition. The customer has been loyal to your company for years, but you will not come out with a replacement of your existing equipment for at least a year. What do you tell the customer?
  9. Which negotiation strategy has the highest risk (possibility of making the customer angry)? Which strategy do you think has the lowest risk (is most effective with customers)?
  10. You are calling on a very large company that has the potential to become your largest customer. How could your sales manager help you be successful in negotiations with this potential customer?

Mini-case 8 Mid-town Office Products

Ron Chambers arrives at work early on Friday morning. His anxiety has been growing throughout his final week of training with Mid-Town Office Products. Today Ron is going to work with his sales manager, Christine Wright, on negotiating customer concerns. He wants to make sure he has plenty of time to prepare and rehearse for the types of objections he is likely to encounter while calling on clients in his new territory (downtown Los Angeles). He will start working this territory next Monday. While Ron waits for Christine to arrive, he sits down and reviews his list of the concerns he is likely to hear from his potential customers.

Mid-Town is a regional distributor of office supply products ranging from pens and paper to small office machines like shredders and fax machines. The product line boasts over 11,000 catalog items. Mid-Town has been in existence for 12 years and operates a warehouse in Cucamonga, on the eastern outskirts of Los Angeles. Mid-Town has grown into a company with a reputation for providing customers with excellent value. It competes with other office supply firms by offering next-day delivery of all orders along with a price that, while not as low as some mail-order firms’, is quite competitive from a total value perspective. In addition to volume discounts, the company maintains a database to help customers track how they use their office supplies. A final feature is a dedicated website so customers can place orders over the Internet. Orders placed via Internet by 4:00 p.m. are delivered the next day.

Mid-Town’s extensive product line, reasonable pricing with volume discounts, next-day delivery, usage history, and Internet ordering have allowed the company to enjoy much success serving small businesses and companies in the eastern Los Angeles suburbs. This success has led the company to expand beyond its traditional customer base of suburban Los Angeles into the heart of the downtown area. Such an expansion is risky for Mid-Town because of the very different customer base and location. However, Mid-Town has decided it can afford to place one representative in downtown Los Angeles for up to two years to try and build the business. Knowing that the success of this venture hinges on his ability to win new business with the larger downtown prospects makes Ron even more anxious about his new assignment.

Ron accepted this position after a successful 8-year career selling copy machines to downtown businesses for a local distributor of a well-known brand. A competitor recently purchased his previous employer. Ron knows that selling office products for Mid-Town will be quite different from selling office machines, and a key part of that difference will be customer concerns. That’s why Ron is eager to hone his skills so he can respond effectively to each objection. Ron also knows that, even though he’ll be calling on some of the same accounts that used to buy his copy machines, the office supplies buyer has a lower job level and less responsibility than the copy machine buyer. As Ron refines the list of objections he expects to get from these buyers, Christine walks in and begins discussing how he can respond to them.

Questions
  1. Identify the potential sources of concern that Ron is likely to encounter when he begins to make calls on his customers in downtown Los Angeles.
  2. Write out two responses for Ron using two separate negotiation strategies to the following customer concern from an office supply buyer for a large downtown bank: “We don’t want you delivering during banking hours. Bringing in big boxes of supplies will upset our operations and our customers who are here trying to conduct business. Our current supplier makes deliveries before 6:30 in the morning and I don’t see any need to change.”
  3. How can Ron effectively respond to any concerns about the prices of Mid-Town’s office supplies being higher than those of mail-order competitors?
..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset