186Managing Individuals
Whatever the particulars, these assignments are a calculated risk on
everyone’s part: the company, your employee, and you. If your employee
succeeds, the company benefi ts from their talent, and they get an impres-
sive new responsibility. You get the satisfaction of seeing your direct re-
port shine, a reputational refraction of their success, and (depending on
the assignment) the use of their talents in a brand-new way. If they fail,
though, everyone feels the downside. Your company might incur losses in
productivity or profi t; your employee, deeply demoralized, may take a big
step back in their career path; and you must manage the fallout to your
unit and your good name.
All this means that you’d better choose carefully, says Claudio
Fernández- Aráoz, a senior adviser at the global executive search fi rm Egon
Zehnder. Whether you’re recommending your employee for a position else-
where in the company or reassigning them on your own team, there are a
few questions you should ask yourself:
Do they really have what it takes?
Their intelligence, creativity, and work ethic are probably well known to
you. But other intangibles, more diffi cult to evaluate, matter just as much.
Are they motivated by a desire to help others succeed or chiefl y by a selfi sh
ambition? Do they have the right leadership assets—resilience, sociability,
and the willingness to learn? Are they really prepared to accept the per-
sonal costs of a more strenuous position?
Is it the right opportunity?
Fernández-Aráoz argues that “the sweet spot of development for high
achievers is when you have a 50–70% chance of success.” You’re looking for
an assignment that the employee has a real shot of completing, but where
they will genuinely have to fi ght for their success. As you evaluate the
match, don’t limit yourself to considerations of skill and experience. What
about the cultural fi t? Will your direct report have any social capital to
draw on in this posting? Review, too, the consequences for your company
(and yourself) if this assignment doesn’t pan out. How much damage could
a failure infl ict? Would you be able to recover?