‘Doctor, I am so sorry to trouble you. I have this real inferiority complex ... but ... it’s not a very big one!’
Once you have mastered and nurtured your self-esteem, the next stage in your self-development programme is to spend some time with the first cousin of self-esteem: self-confidence.
Self-confidence comes under several guises including, but not limited to, self-belief, self-assurance and self-regard. Perhaps another way of thinking about it is that self-esteem is internal. It’s how you think and feel about yourself. If your self-esteem is strong then this affects how you behave in the world, i.e. your external behaviour. High self-esteem is the engine that drives self-confidence.
With all these shades of meaning it might be helpful to suggest a definition which will clarify the concept:
This is the ability to behave with poise and control in both personal and social situations, knowing that this is possible irrespective of your standing in society, your education, ethnicity, sexual orientation or religious and political affiliations.
So self-confidence is essentially an attitude towards self and life in general. It is a conviction about your own abilities – that you have reasonable control over yourself and your life. Since confident individuals have realistic expectations of themselves, which includes recognising and accepting their weaknesses, they do not assume that they are good at everything – they are always ready to learn.
Self-confidence is critical to our psychological wellbeing. Being without confidence is like being the pilot of a plane and realising that you have just run out of fuel – the only way is down. It’s healthy to exercise choice and personal preferences in life but it becomes dangerous if we choose not to like ourselves and prefer not to be ‘us’. It is of no consequence psychologically to prefer coffee to tea or Beethoven to Bach, but it’s not healthy to prefer to be someone other than who you are.
To always judge and criticise yourself is emotionally damaging and leads you to spiral down and, in some extreme cases, into that black hole we call depression.
Are we born with too much or too little of this precious characteristic? Yes and no, but it doesn’t matter if we were not given the right genes at birth because it’s possible to develop self-confidence since it is not a dispositional trait, but a characteristic. Some psychologists have suggested that self-confidence is something that we act on rather than intrinsically have. Perhaps we should remember that babies, before they can even talk, are certainly not backward in coming forward with great confidence for the things they want. Whatever the cognitive hoops babies struggle to jump through as they work hard to understand their confusing world, I’m sure that thoughts such as:
will not figure significantly in their cognitive pre-verbal ruminations.
What happened to us? Well, for a whole variety of reasons, we developed voices in our heads. Some of the voices we developed when comparing ourselves to others – ‘I’m not as clever/not as good looking/not as fluent’, and, later in life, ‘not as rich/not as important/not as influential’ – and then turning these observations into negative thoughts about ourselves which we believe, and then we behave as if they were true and immutable facts in all future situations.
We don’t go to the dentist to hear how the enamel and dentine has been eroded and the inner living pulp of the affected tooth is being irritated by bacterial toxins, thus delivering an up-close and very personal toothache – we just want it fixed and our pain to go away. Consequently the ‘how’ we arrived at our current level of self-confidence is not as important as the ‘what’ we can do about it.
You might view yourself as a victim of your past (genetics, parents, upbringing or unfortunate significant emotional events). Here we have to think and act as a person who has decided to work on and develop themselves in certain areas of their choosing. You have no choice, you have to go with what you’ve got and who you are. The best advice is to be like Popeye whose mantra was:
‘I yam what I yam and I do what I can because I yam Popeye the Sailor Man.’
By working through this chapter you might begin to think that your particular situation is worse than you first imagined – let me assure you it isn’t. So now let’s turn to examine self-confidence with particular emphasis on what has the potential to reduce and damage it.
Regrettably, sometimes, the voices were ‘planted’ in our heads by significant others when we were very young. Parents tell their children they ‘are lazy’, they ‘are disorganised’ or, even worse, they ‘will not amount to much’ or they ‘are stupid’. Close family members such as older siblings or grandparents, even friends of the family, through their negative comments can also be guilty. Planting negative thoughts will breed negative voices. By the time you reach adulthood the voices are firmly anchored into your subconscious; you believe they are true and act accordingly.
Way back in 600 BC the Book of Proverbs states:
‘As a man thinks in his heart, so is he.’ (23:7) |
Personally, as I’m dyslexic, I was instructed, at the age of eight, by my teacher, to stand in front of the class and say three times in a loud voice, ‘I am stupid, stupid, stupid.’ Although I managed it through my tears, in a way it was great because being stupid encouraged me to put all my efforts into sport. It was a great relief to hear my father say on production of my school report gleaming with academic failures, ‘Never mind, son, it takes a good brain to resist education.’ However, this ‘you are stupid’ voice was very persistent, bubbling up at regular intervals. Thinking of myself as stupid was still ringing in my ears during my late teens and early twenties. It was not until I was 45 with three degrees, several postgrad diplomas and, at that time, 44 letters after my name parading my credentials, that I realised that I was stupid in collecting qualifications and even more stupid to have had that voice embedded in my brain for 37 years. It was a huge relief to say, ‘Stuff night school, I want to play the guitar; stuff all this academic study, I want to ride horses.’
Inappropriate critical voices that are dumped upon us, sometimes with extremely adverse effects on our self-confidence, might include:
Yours not here ? Then please add it to the list to recognise the enemy.
These are just some of the inappropriate ‘I am’ voices and statements that abound in our heads and affect our lives and development adversely.
Many children of the last century were brought up with the nursery rhyme:
‘What are little boys made of?
Slugs and snails, and puppy-dogs’ tails,
That’s what little boys are made of.
What are little girls made of?
Sugar and spice, and everything nice,
That’s what little girls are made of.’
Robert Southey (who became Poet Laureate in England in 1813)
So it’s not surprising that some people are victims of ‘cultural voices’ such as:
All of us have voices in our heads. Ask anyone the question, ‘Do you have voices in your head?’ and unless they say ‘Yes’ immediately, you can then say to them, ‘I bet you are saying to yourself, “Do I have voices in my head?”’. They will laugh because we all have those voices.
And here we can see, hear and feel the danger of our self-confidence just dribbling away if we allow such negative statements to rattle around in our subconscious, imbue us with self-doubt and attempt to scuttle our self-belief.
We will look at how to banish these confidence terrorists but, for me, Henry Ford stated it perfectly with:
‘If you think you are or if you think you are not; you are right.’
What he actually said was ‘If you think you can or think you can’t, you’re right’, but I don’t think he would mind the adaption!
Sometimes we are our own worst enemy. To the detriment of our self-confidence we frequently donate and bequeath these pernicious voices to ourselves through our own faulty thinking. The sequence of events leading up to the birth of these troubling inner demons is usually that we have tried to do something different or experiment with a new behaviour only to find ourselves in a situation where it all goes pear-shaped. As we venture to rationalise or understand this unwanted fruit of failure we become victims of our own faulty thinking. It comes in at least six different and inappropriate thought disguises.
Here are some examples of what we can do to ourselves:
If we fail once then we will always fail. Thus we generalise from one instance to all similar future situations.
‘I made a poor speech two years ago. I’m definitely not good at public speaking.’
Rejecting all praise and recalling only the bad things. When your glasses are tinted blue then the bottles of life are, at best, half empty!
‘That was a great speech!’
‘Yes, but I don’t think I got my message across.’
Making everything your responsibility; whatever goes wrong then it must be your fault.
‘I know lots of people were late. I should have known that the snow was so bad. I should have started my speech much later; it’s entirely my fault.’
This is where you have fully developed your nascent gift of being able to read other people’s minds.
‘I just know, by looking at them, that they thought my speech was nonsense.’
You always feel the need to apologise for everything that ever goes wrong.
‘I’m so sorry that your equipment failed during my speech. It’s my fault: I should have asked you to double-check it before I went on. I’m so sorry.’
Here you polarise your reasoning about your performance or behaviour so that you were either absolutely fantastic or a total failure. For you there is no middle ground of success. You either give your self an ‘A plus’ or an ‘F minus’, because your actions are judged by yourself to be either black or white. There are no shades of grey in your self-evaluation pallet.
‘I stumbled over the pronunciation of Alkylphenol Polyethoxylate when talking in front of my peers, so I must be totally useless at giving presentations!’
When you employ this faulty thinking about yourself the internal critic claims yet another victory, your confidence oozes down into your black hole of self-doubt and you excuse yourself from facing similar situations where you ‘failed’. Low self-confidence goes hand in hand with self-restriction.
Here are a dirty dozen ways we limit ourselves, but I’m sure there are some more from those negative voices in your own head as well as mine:
Here is a very quick little questionnaire. There are no right or wrong answers, but remember if your answers are not the truth you will not get a true score, so be honest with yourself!
Give yourself 1 for never, 2 for sometimes and 3 for usually.
Now add up your scores:
30–36: You are quite low on self-confidence and self-promotion activities are likely to be difficult for you.
24–29: On occasions you lack self-confidence.
20–23: You are about the same as most people in the self-confidence stakes.
17–20: You are a self-confident person.
12–16: You may be suffering from motivated distortion (psych jargon for fibbing on the questionnaire!) or, worse, possibly hubris – do the questionnaire again – no one is that confident!
If you genuinely scored less than 17 you might like to skip this section of the book rather than spending valuable time on what you cannot do!
One more trick of the internal voice critic is the tyranny of ‘must’s’, ‘ought’s’ and ‘should’s’ that we get given by our family upbringing, education and culture. How many of these are familiar?
There are also some ‘don’ts’ which are just as tyrannical:
Not that all such imperatives are inappropriate, especially those that come mainly from our culture and experience. So you would be wise, for example:
Frivolous, but you know what I mean. None of these axioms will endanger your self-confidence, in fact, some of them might be very helpful.
It’s surprising that we listen to these inner voices, especially when they do our self-confidence so much harm. But there are two compelling reasons:
Our parents, or those emotionally significant to us, drummed it into us that we must, ought to and should show respect and accept what they told us. It was a trade since we needed their love, approval and recognition. Emotionally it’s very difficult to come to the conclusion that your parents have feet of clay and in some things they are definitely wrong.
We don’t want to take the untried risk of changing – although inadequate, we feel safe in the thick shells of our inadequacies: ‘If it ain’t broke why improve it?’
We can excuse our behaviour because the inner voice confirms who we are; it alleviates our responsibility for not trying:
The outcomes are predictable. If you believe that, ‘Because I’m socially inept they will not invite me’, when you don’t get the invite you are not surprised because you predicted your omission on the social list and this confirms your inner voice.
Not only is this difficult but the prize for persistence goes to this inner critic in that it never leaves us alone and we, for the most part, can’t but stop and listen.
Sometimes this self-protection from not doing something requested of you takes an interesting and amusing turn. On being requested to assist in the post-dinner washing-up, my daughter, who is also challenged in the spelling and writing department, came up with this:
Marisian: | ‘But, Dad, I don’t do washing up.’ |
Me: | ‘Why is that, Marisian?’ |
Marisian: | ‘Oh, Dad, you know why! It’s because I’m dyslexic’. |
Now, just as much as this is amusing, it’s not much different from an internal voice:
Statement: | ‘I will never get married.’ |
Inner question: | ‘Why won’t you ever get married?’ |
Answer: | ‘Because I’m shy.’ |
And this would be amusing if it wasn’t true. One claimed incompetence leads to a totally false assumption which has no rational connection, with usually unfortunate outcomes. Remember the Henry Ford quote:
‘If you think you can or you think you can’t. You are right.’ |
It strikes in certain situations when we are faced with something we have not attempted, for example:
In a social situation, if you tell yourself that you will be excluded, guess what? You will be. If you think you are a bad presenter, guess what? You will be. If you think that no one will go on a date with you, guess what? You’re going to miss out on a lot of dates.
People whose inner critic tells them that they are unattractive sometimes do nothing to improve their attractiveness and gradually, by letting themselves go and not caring about themselves, they really do become unattractive. In life we are very much our own prophets fulfilling our own expectations.
‘Our doubts are traitors and make us lose the good we oft might win, by fearing to attempt.’ William Shakespeare, Measure for Measure |
Well, that is all the bad news so, before we imitate the hermit crab and scurry back into our protective shell and hide from the world, let’s see what is possible to change.
It would be wonderful if we could develop a selective deafness to deal with these voices, but unfortunately they have been chiming in our heads for so long that they have become almost hardwired. ‘I am disorganised’ comes into your head so quickly before you even commence a complicated task. Then you say to yourself, ‘I must not be disorganised about this.’ But here is the thing; the brain has difficulties when dealing with negatives because it has to unpack them first. If you tell yourself, ‘I must not be disorganised’, your brain has to think about being ‘disorganised’ first before it can reverse it and think of the positive ‘organised’ state. Rather like a parent telling a child, ‘Don’t play in the road’, the embedded sentence which the child hears first is, ‘Play in the road.’ How much better to say, ‘Play in the park.’ So what to do?
I had a friend once who was able to get all her voices out of her head and onto her shoulder as if they were parrots. On reflection she could recognise many of them. There was her mother: ‘You are lazy’, ‘You will never be a success.’ There was her jealous elder sister: ‘You are ugly.’ There was her teacher: ‘You will never come to anything.’ There was her first boyfriend: ‘You will never be any good at relationships.’ So many parrots, but who the voice belonged to was recognised.
Now my friend could say to herself when the parrot spoke, ‘I hear you, Mother, but you are wrong’, or she could just choose to knock the parrot (aka the person) off its perch on her shoulder, or she could choose to listen.
I have worked with captains of industry, top civil servants and even generals and, guess what, as successful as they are, they all had negative inner voices concerning their abilities. Here is an actual quote from a brigadier with whom I worked whose inner voice was ‘I am not good at strategy.’
You will remember that the conversation went like this: ‘If I was as good at strategy as Sir Peter over there, I would have made general.’ Where did that come from? Perhaps, when the brigadier was just a junior subaltern, his then captain, who he admired greatly, had told him during a review that his strategic ability was poor.
One wonders how much further up the hierarchy the brigadier would have risen if he had said to himself when he had the opportunity to be strategic, ‘I hear you, Captain, but I choose to ignore you because I have worked on my abilities, taken advice from my mentors and read extensively.’
List all the negative voices that you have and then work hard on discovering who the significant person behind them is. Your negative voices can come from all sorts of people including, but not limited to:
Once you recognise the owner of the voice it’s much easier to deal with and eradicate it.
If you cannot recognise where the voice is coming from, no matter, just give it a name and use it when necessary: ‘Oh here comes “Big Mouth” trying to put me down again.’
Just because you have failed before does not necessarily mean that you will fail again. In life you quickly learn what you can and can’t do. But one failure doesn’t mean continual failure. It gives you experience of how to tackle the opportunity again in terms of learning preparation and practice (see below).
Just as when we grow physically we can reach further, so as we journey through life with all its lessons we are better equipped to try again. If you concentrate and worry about what happened in the past then you become closed and shut to new opportunities that life presents. It’s always easier to say ‘No’ to opportunity, but you miss a lot and dive into the pit of self-justification.
Has there ever been a time when a disappointment has turned out to be a blessing? Think of the boyfriend or girlfriend who dumped you, or the job you didn’t get – have you now moved onto bigger and better things because of those setbacks?
On many occasions, in retrospect a difficulty has turned out to be a blessing in disguise. A reversal is discovering the silver lining of the dark cloud. It’s a way of putting a stop sign in front of your inner critic and instead getting your mind to look at the benefits you will have gained. Should you be criticised or should something happen to you which initially disappoints you, makes you feel inadequate or knocks your self-confidence, then this reversal strategy works very well.
Here you take apart the content of the critical voice, being very specific about what is true but then balancing it within the total context, which is also true. Remembering what was covered in dealing with ‘fat’ words, here are some examples:
Fact: I am anxious about meeting new people for the first time, but once the ice is broken and I have got to know them, then my contribution to the discussion is as good as anyone’s, my views are accepted and my company is enjoyed. So, I am socially competent.
Fact: I am shorter than average and I’m not as fit as I could be but I have lovely skin and hair and many people have complimented me on my dress sense. So, I am attractive.
Fact: I do find it difficult to understand complicated new systems but, once I have mastered the process, I’ve no difficulty at all. In fact I have trained new staff in many of the systems that I initially found difficult. So I am organised.
Fact: I am lazy but only in doing those things that I am not interested in. In topics or things I find interesting or I think are important, I’m highly motivated.
Fact:Yes, sometimes I can be if I’m tired or have too much on my plate, but at all other times I’m on an even keel and people seek my company and invite me to their social gatherings. So, in general I’m calm and even-tempered.
Notice in all the above examples that the conclusion (fact) is always written in the positive. For example, ‘I am attractive’ is written in preference to ‘I am not unattractive’, so you avoid thinking about the negative before you can get to the positive implication.
If you are fortunate you can be given, by somebody who is close to you, a positive voice which will wipe out and reverse the negative voice. Here is an example, a self-disclosure about my spelling ability:
Teacher: | ‘Eggert, you are stupid, stupid, stupid. What are you?’ |
My father: | ‘Never mind son, it takes a good brain to resist an education.’ |
Inner voice: | ‘Being challenged in my ability to spell does not equate with stupidity and I have been blessed with a good brain.’ |
Make a list of all the things you are proud of, together with a list of your achievements. (These should already be in your log book from a previous activity.) What are the common threads in your list? What does it say about what you are good at? Give yourself credit for what you have done and, when doubts strike, revisit your list.
You are not the sum of other people’s views of you. Evaluate yourself and your behaviour independently of others. Do not give credence to the criticism of others but evaluate it and take on board what you find useful.
If you lack confidence in doing certain things such as giving a speech, wanting to persuade someone, leading a project, and so on, then you would do well to prepare far more diligently than most other people. Do your research, develop contingency plans, practise talking out loud to yourself and ask yourself lots of ‘what if’ questions so that you can be really on top of what you are going to do.
Of course, doing new things and being successful is a great boost to self-confidence. Should you fail, then rejoice, because life has just given you another learning opportunity. It’s not always possible to learn from others. In failing, you give yourself a unique learning opportunity. As we have said before, ‘you get things right by getting them wrong.’ Just think, when you were a baby, you fell on your bottom hundreds of times but persistence paid off and it was not long before you were walking.
Also, when you fail you realise that it’s not the end of the world – the sky did not fall. Not only do people who are important to you still love and like you despite your failure, but when you try again they will admire you.
‘Confidence comes not from always being right but from not fearing to be wrong.’ Peter T. McIntyre, lithographic artist |
Make an unequivocal promise to yourself that you are totally dedicated to acting confidently. This may sound like ‘fake it till you make it’ but just as belief turns into behaviour so, in a similar way, behaviour turns into beliefs.
Slowly begin to stretch yourself in your personal goals. Increase your motivation and keep up your self-talk to succeed and you will be surprised at what you can achieve. Be realistic in what you want to achieve, set your mind to it and, in the words of the Nike slogan: ‘Just do it.’
Smile. Self-confident people are self-assured and positive. We smile when we are happy so smile appropriately when with others – nobody grins all the time. Smiling will make you appear confident and people will treat you as such, and this feedback will help you become more confident.
This activity is useful in identifying your various capabilities and positive attributes. After you have completed the following statements you might like to share your answers with a friend or someone who knows you well and who could probably suggest some additions. Complete the sentences that follow:
Something I do well is _____________________
Something I’m complimented on is ______________________
At work I am good at ___________________________
I am proud that at work I ______________________
My greatest strength at work is ____________________
At work I can help others to ___________________
My greatest strength outside work is __________________
What I like best about myself is __________________
I have the power to _________________________
I was able to decide to ______________________
People can’t make me _____________________
I am strong enough to ______________________
I’m not afraid to ________________________
Something that I can do now that I couldn’t do last year is ____________
I used to have difficulty dealing with ____________________
but this is no longer a problem.
I have accomplished _________________________
If I want to I can ___________________________
People like me because _______________________
My greatest achievement is _________________________
I have the courage to ______________________
Note: this activity highlights some of the many talents you possess. Concentrate on developing this list further.
Go back to the life line activity that you completed earlier and, in your log book or on paper, make a detailed list of all your achievements above the line under three headings:
The next stage is to expand each achievement in a special way called ‘FABing’, which stands for:
When failure strikes, as it always does when we are pushing the boundaries in life and work, we feel disappointed with ourselves, and thump self-confidence. Should this occur, then just take out and read your achievement list to yourself out loud. This will remind you of your successes in the three important areas of your life. When you do push the boundaries and you are successful then add that achievement to your list.
A wonderful psychological power of your achievement list is the sure and certain knowledge that you achieved those elements and no one can ever diminish or take them away from you.
1 Adapted from Robert C. Pozen, Extreme Productivity: Boost Your Results, Reduce Your Hours, Harper Business (2012).