Cases

Fire On the Ground

At the beginning of this chapter, you read about Fogo de Chão and how the restaurant chain has grown from a single location in Brazil to an international operation. Using the information presented in this chapter, you should be able to answer the following questions:

  1. 17-23. When the Coser and Ongaratto brothers started Fogo de Chão, what were their primary sources of financing?

  2. 17-24. After the Coser brothers acquired the Ongaratto brothers’ shares of the company, they brought in GP Investments, a Brazilian venture capital firm. What are the advantages and disadvantages of using venture capital to build a business venture?

  3. 17-25. After the sale of Fogo de Chão to Thomas H. Lee Partners, the board and management team decided to issue an IPO of common stock. What were the goals of the IPO?

  4. 17-26. What are the benefits of an IPO as a source of financing? What other options did the company have?

  5. 17-27. Would you consider investing in Fogo de Chão? Why, or why not?

  6. 17-28. If an investor had bought stock during the IPO, what would that investment be worth today?

Time to Gogo?

If you’ve flown lately, you may be familiar with the in-flight Internet service Gogo. The company’s roots go back to 1991, when the company, then called Aircell, developed technology for in-flight phone services. In 2006, the company made a major change in strategy when it secured a 10-year license through the Federal Communications Commission for in-flight Internet services. Industry leaders, including Virgin America, Delta, United, and Frontier, have been offering Gogo in-flight services since 2008. Southwest is the only major airline in the United States not aligned with Gogo, having signed an agreement with a competitor, Row 44.19

Gogo realized that international expansion is critical to its long-term plan. Though it can achieve greater saturation of the domestic market by having its equipment installed on more planes, international expansion is the key to turning a profit. The company has begun this effort, signing an agreement with Delta to install its equipment on all 170 planes in Delta’s international fleet.

To raise the money needed for a major expansion, Gogo raised $187 million in a June 2013 IPO, underwritten by Wall Street heavy hitters such as Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan, and UBS, hitting the market at $17 per share.20 The price of the stock fell quickly over the following months, bottoming out at just over $10, but then recovered and hit a high of almost $33 in December. Since then, the stock has steadily declined, but it seems to have hit a floor of about $10.

The enormous technology and operating costs associated with expanding its network have resulted in losses each year and a weak December 31, 2016, balance sheet, with liabilities in excess of assets, $800 million in long-term debt, and a negative equity balance, despite almost $880 million in capital invested. Most of the company’s common and preferred stock is still held by company executives and a number of mutual funds and venture capital firms.21

The company has made a major investment in improving the speed of its service with the Gogo 2Ku systems installed in 2016. As Gogo moves to penetrate the international market and increase access and speed, investors in Gogo stock could see a huge return on investment. However, there’s certainly considerable uncertainty about the future and only time will tell if this risky investment will pay off.22

Questions for Discussion

  1. 17-29. Given the risk, what would motivate an investor to purchase stock in Gogo?

  2. 17-30. Why would Gogo sell stock rather than taking on additional debt financing? Do you think that this was a good decision?

  3. 17-31. What role did underwriters, such as Morgan Stanley, JPMorgan, and UBS, play in the IPO?

  4. 17-32. Use a Web source, such as Yahoo! Finance or www.nasdaq.com, obtain the current price of Gogo stock. What has happened to the price of the stock over the last six months? What about the last two years?

  5. 17-33. Using the data provided from the web source in the previous step, is Gogo a small or large cap stock? How would this affect the risk associated with this investment?

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset