BOARD OF DIRECTORS
CEO as chairman
A setup in which the company’s CEO serves as the board’s
chairman. While this offers less independent scrutiny of
finances, strategy, performance, and pay, it avoids duplication
of roles. This setup is found in US corporations and in many
small- and medium-sized companies in other countries.
Balancing the board
The board has three clear areas of
responsibility: developing business
strategy, advising the company,
and overseeing how the firm is run.
Selecting the right mix of directors
to fulfill these functions is crucial.
Board members may come from
inside or outside the company.
Those who work for the company
(executive or internal directors)
have more expertise in running
the business, but independent
members (non-executive or external
directors) are better placed to offer
perspective, scrutinize the actions
Independent board of directors
The board sits between shareholders and company. The
CEO is the main channel of communication between board
and company, while the chairman is the principal conduit
between shareholders and board. This structure gives the
board most independence.
of company executives, and call
them to account. When potential
conflicts of interest arise between
management and shareholders,
independent directors can weigh
decision-making in favor of acting
in the company’s best interests.
The ideal balance is a hot topic
in corporate governance. In US
companies, CEO and chairman roles
have traditionally been combined,
but following a spate of corporate
scandals, the roles are now more
often vested in two individuals. In
Europe, keeping the roles separate
has long been seen as best practice.
Shareholders
Board of directors
Management and
employees
Board of directors
Chairman
and CEO
Management and
employees
Shareholders
CEO
Shareholders
Chairman Treasurer
Secretary
Key
Board structure variations
NEDs Non-executive directors,
also known as independent,
external, or outside directors
Executive directors Board
members who also work for the
company—not to be confused with
the term executive director when
used as a title for the CEO
Model Business Corporation
Act Developed by the American
Bar Association, this model is used
as the basis for corporate
governance in the US
NEED TO KNOW
US_052-055_Board_of_directors.indd 54 21/11/2014 16:38
54 55
how companies work
Who’s who
Two-tier board
An arrangement that is made up of separate supervisory
and executive boards. The supervisory board is composed
of outside directors, led by a chairman. The executive
board comprises senior managers, including the CEO.
The two boards always meet separately.
Senior management as directors
A structure in which senior managers also sit on the board.
The chief financial officer (CFO) is appointed board treasurer
and the chief operations officer (COO) is vice-chairman. In
some countries (Germany, for example), employees must
be included on the board by law.
Board of directors
Supervisory board
Executive board
Management and
employees
Management and
employees
Shareholders Shareholders
Treasurer
and CFO
Vice-chairman
and COO
Chairman
and CEO
44%
of S&P 500-listed
companies had
distinct CEO and
chairman roles in
2012—up from
21% in 2001
Management and employees
CEO
Vice-chairman Other directors
CEO and board
member
Employee and
board member
PROS AND CONS OF CEO AS CHAIRMAN
Pros
Strong, central leadership
Decisions hold fewer conflicts.
Efficiency CEO/chairman can
implement board decisions swiftly.
Expertise CEO has company and
industry knowledge (a CEO may
become chairman after retirement).
Balance of power Established
hierarchy between CEO/chairman
and other directors reduces risk
of conflict on the board.
Cons
Lack of transparency Conflicts of
interest/corruption are more likely.
Reduced objectivity Board
headed by CEO is unable to monitor
CEO’s work objectively.
Higher remuneration Combined
role generally commands higher pay
than two separate individuals.
Mentoring Chairman who is
also CEO cannot offer independent
mentoring and support for the role.
US_052-055_Board_of_directors.indd 55 21/11/2014 16:38