Cons

The following are the cons of using focus group or visioning activity:

  • It is logistically complex to organize--the need to gather participants who share common attributes that match the needs of the research.
  • It requires sufficient lead time in the project to plan the event, find an appropriate venue, and recruit participants.
  • Geographical and space limitations pose a restriction on the number of total sessions that can be conducted and their location, and as a result, limits the overall pool of participants to those who are in close proximity.
  • It often requires the services of a recruiting firm.
  • It requires significant investment of time to create activities that will enable participants to provide feedback both as a group and an individual.
  • It requires an experienced facilitator who can guide the discussions in an engaging way, and also control participants and ensure an equal voice to as many viewpoints.
  • Focus groups are notorious for being easily impacted by group dynamics:
    • They are diverted to a specific direction by vocal and opinionated participants, and there is no contribution from shy participants
    • Group Think, where individuals in the group are adopting the majority view and are not voicing their own opinion
  • Monetary incentives are often required to recruit participants. As with any research activity that is not voluntary, there is a risk that a participant's contribution is seen as a means to getting paid, as opposed to making a product better.
  • Documenting the session is challenging--it is difficult to take notes when multiple discussions or activities are taking place, difficult to get a good video or audio recording in a room full of participants, and expensive - often impossible, to transcribe the recordings.

Many UX practitioners find the focus group's cons--which are listed here--to be so overwhelming that they reject this method altogether as a valid UX research method. Still, there are circumstances for which the benefits might justify this activity.

..................Content has been hidden....................

You can't read the all page of ebook, please click here login for view all page.
Reset